The Pittsburgh Pirates are navigating a challenging season, prompting speculation about whether they might consider shutting down star pitcher Paul Skenes. With the team struggling to find its footing, the decision to manage Skenes' workload has become a focal point for fans and analysts alike.
Despite the team's overall difficulties, Skenes' individual performance has not been entirely disappointing. His 3.88 ERA is respectable, and he boasts a 2.99 FIP, which indicates that his effectiveness as a pitcher remains strong when accounting for defensive support. Additionally, he has a solid WHIP of 1.12, suggesting that he is generally limiting baserunners.
However, there are concerns regarding Skenes' velocity, which has noticeably declined. On August 11, he reached a top speed of 96.5 mph, with a season average of 96.8 mph on his four-seam fastball, down from an impressive 98.2 mph in 2025. This drop-off raises questions about his ability to perform at the elite level he showcased during his first two seasons, leading to uncertainty about his future with the Pirates.
During a recent game against the Miami Marlins, Skenes was pulled after just five innings and 65 pitches, a decision that raised eyebrows. Manager Don Kelly clarified that the move was not due to injury but rather a strategic choice. This decision came after Skenes had allowed only one earned run, though he faced challenges that could have changed the game's outcome, including a near home run that was saved by a defensive play from teammate Bryan Reynolds.
Kelly's comments before the game highlighted the adjustments Skenes needs to make as opposing teams adapt to his pitching style. He acknowledged that while Skenes' velocity is down, command issues may be contributing to his struggles. Kelly emphasized the importance of Skenes finding a way to adjust, suggesting that the pitcher might be trying too hard to regain his previous velocity.
Given the context of Skenes' workload this season, which included preparation for the World Baseball Classic and a career-high 187 innings pitched during his Cy Young-winning campaign in 2025, the Pirates may be taking a cautious approach. To maintain Skenes' health and effectiveness, the team could be looking to limit his innings as they face a bleak playoff picture, now sitting six games behind the San Diego Padres and Philadelphia Phillies for the final wild-card spot in the National League.
As the Pirates continue to struggle offensively—failing to score any runs in the recent game against the Marlins—managing Skenes' workload may be a prudent strategy. With playoff odds dwindling to just 4.4%, the focus may shift from pushing for a postseason berth to ensuring the long-term health and performance of their star pitcher.
After the game, Skenes expressed a sense of progress in his performance, indicating that he understood the decision to limit his innings. He acknowledged that he felt he was making better pitches earlier in counts and seemed to support the management's approach, stating, "If I were the manager, I’d probably do it, too." This indicates a level of professionalism and understanding as he navigates the challenges of the season.
Leave a Comment