The NFL is notorious for roster decisions that seem logical in the preseason but can appear misguided as the regular season unfolds. The Dallas Cowboys' recent decision to waive quarterback Joe Milton has sparked discussions among fans and analysts alike, particularly as the team prepares for the challenges of the upcoming season.
On August 16, 2025, the Cowboys made the surprising choice to cut Milton in order to accommodate running back Emari Demercado. This decision effectively positioned Sam Howell as the primary backup to starting quarterback Dak Prescott. While roster flexibility is essential, the implications of this move could be felt if Prescott encounters any setbacks during the season.
Milton's preseason performance was noteworthy, as he completed 29 of 43 passes for 378 yards, contributing three touchdowns and no interceptions. Additionally, he showcased his versatility by rushing for another score. This impressive showing suggests that Milton was not merely a developmental quarterback struggling to find his footing in the NFL; rather, he demonstrated the potential to be a valuable backup who was improving with each game.
Interestingly, just days before his release, Cowboys offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer expressed confidence in both Howell and Milton as capable backups. The sudden decision to part ways with Milton left many questioning the rationale behind the move. Jon Machota, a reporter covering the Cowboys, highlighted the unexpected nature of the release, noting that backup quarterback is not a position where teams should prioritize roster efficiency over potential game-winning ability.
While Howell may provide a steadier option, Milton's exceptional arm strength and physical capabilities could have offered the Cowboys a different level of contingency should Prescott miss time. The Cowboys are built to compete at a high level this season, and retaining a quarterback with game-changing traits could prove crucial in tight situations.
As the season approaches, the Cowboys' decision to release Milton raises concerns about their depth at the quarterback position. If Prescott remains healthy throughout the season, this decision may not have immediate consequences. However, the uncertainty surrounding Prescott's durability makes it imperative for the Cowboys to have a solid backup plan in place.
Looking ahead, there is a palpable sense of anticipation among Cowboys fans regarding the potential impact of this decision. If Prescott faces any challenges by Halloween, the question will inevitably arise: why did the Cowboys let Joe Milton go? The answer to that question could define their season.
Leave a Comment